3T · MOTOR RECYCLING

Is It More Profitable To Sell Scrap Electric Motors Whole Or Dismantle Them?

The Short Answer

Dismantling a scrap electric motor is more profitable when the extra value of the recovered materials exceeds the additional processing costs. Selling whole may be the better option when that margin is small, the motors take too long to process, or you would need equipment for only occasional jobs.

The 191.2 kg worked example below shows 100.89 USD more in material sales revenue after dismantling, before added costs. Use it as a calculation method, then replace the weights, prices and costs with figures from your own motors.

BSM-40 motor recycling machine at the 3T factory.

A 191.2 kg Motor: Compare Revenue Before Costs

Sell whole

63.10 USD

Worked example · gross revenue

Dismantle

163.99 USD

Worked example · gross revenue

Additional revenue

100.89 USD

Worked example · before added costs

Source: BSGH Recycling’s motor dismantling video.
This 191.2 kg case includes 10.35 kg of copper windings and 180.85 kg of other listed materials.
The figures above compare gross material revenue at the article’s example prices. Deduct your actual processing costs to assess the additional return.

Option 1: Dismantle Scrap Motor

For a suitable motor, dismantling involves removing the casing, cutting the stator windings and extracting the copper coils. A BSM-40 motor dismantling machine combines winding cutting and pulling functions; confirm the stator dimensions and tooling before choosing a setup. For the process in more detail, see how to remove copper from an electric motor.

A suitable pulley puller can help with pulley removal where required. Further separation of shafts, bearings, rotors and casings adds handling time, so include those steps in your cost estimate. Sort the resulting materials according to your scrap buyer’s requirements.

Worked example: material weights, assumed prices and gross sales revenue

Recovered Material
Poids
Price
Gross Revenue
Copper Windings
10.35 kg
12.00 USD/kg
124.20 USD
Motor Casing
92.30 kg
Bearings & Steel Parts
46.05 kg
Stator Steel
3.25 kg
Rotor
39.25 kg
0.22 USD/kg
39.79 USD — combined revenue for these four material groups
Total
191.20 kg
163.99 USD

For simplicity, this example values all four non-copper groups together at 0.22 USD/kg: 180.85 kg × 0.22 = 39.787 USD. This shared rate is an assumption, not a claim that every material has the same market value. Use separate buyer quotes wherever grades differ.

Option 2: Sell the Scrap Motor Whole

Using the assumed whole-motor price of 0.33 USD/kg, the same 191.2 kg motor would generate approximately 63.10 USD before any selling costs:

191.2 kg × 0.33 USD/kg = 63.096 USD ≈ 63.10 USD

At these assumed prices, separating the materials increases gross revenue. However, this does not establish how much profit the operator makes. Compare both routes on the same basis, including any differences in transport, handling, buyer deductions and disposal costs.

Additional gross revenue from dismantling: approximately 100.89 USD per motor.

The extra processing costs must stay below approximately 100.89 USD per motor for dismantling to outperform selling whole in this example. Because processing time and operating costs have not been measured here, an actual net-profit figure cannot be established. Use the cost worksheet below to find your own margin.

Example limits: these inputs have no stated quote date, location or buyer grade and should not be treated as current market prices. The listed weights add up to the full motor weight; in your own trial, record unsaleable residue and handling losses separately. This single example does not establish a typical copper yield.

Apply the Comparison to Your Own Scrap Motors

A larger supply alone does not make dismantling profitable. Start with a representative sample of your usual motors, record saleable output and total handling time, and obtain comparable quotes for selling whole and selling the separated materials. Keep motor purchase costs consistent between both options.

1. Check the Motor and the Buyer’s Prices

• Identify the motor type, winding material, size and condition. Do not apply a copper-winding calculation to an aluminum-wound motor or assume a smaller motor has the same material proportions as this example. Confirm that the proposed machine can handle the stator dimensions.

• Ask your buyer how the recovered windings and other materials will be graded, including any deductions for contamination or mixed materials. Use quotes from the same period and account for differences in transport and minimum delivery quantities.

2. Fill In Your Processing Cost per Motor

Cost worksheet — complete using your own trial:

  • Labor: total worker-hours per motor × hourly labor cost = ___
  • Electricity: measured kWh per motor × electricity tariff = ___
  • Blades, tooling and routine maintenance allowance = ___
  • Extra transport, handling and disposal costs = ___
  • Total additional operating cost per motor = ___

Count setup, casing removal, cutting, pulling, sorting and cleanup. Two people working for half an hour equal one worker-hour. Include your own time even if you operate the machine yourself. Only include costs that differ between the two routes, and do not deduct a buyer’s allowance twice if it is already reflected in the quoted price.

Additional operating margin per motor = separated-material revenue − whole-motor revenue − additional operating costs. A positive result supports dismantling with existing suitable equipment; a negative result favors selling whole under those inputs. This margin is before recovering a new machine’s purchase cost and before tax or financing costs.

If You Need a New Machine: Check the Payback

A profitable processing job does not automatically justify buying equipment. Estimate how many suitable motors you can actually process and sell each month, allowing for available labor, downtime and an irregular supply. Use this realistic volume when estimating payback.

Simple payback worksheet:

  • Initial equipment investment, including delivery and installation = ___
  • Monthly additional cash contribution = margin per motor × realistic motors per month − any new monthly fixed operating costs = ___
  • Estimated payback months = initial investment ÷ monthly additional cash contribution

Use operating cash costs in this payback calculation. Do not deduct the full equipment purchase price or depreciation again from the monthly contribution. If the contribution is zero or negative, the investment does not pay back under those assumptions. This simple estimate excludes tax, financing and the time value of money.

Recheck the result with lower scrap prices, fewer motors per month and longer processing times. If a modest change removes the margin, keep selling whole or gather better trial data before investing. Dismantling is the stronger option when measured output, processing costs and a dependable supply support it.

Find a Suitable Setup for Your Scrap Motors

Send 3T photos of your scrap motors, stator dimensions, estimated monthly volume and local prices for whole motors and separated materials. Tell us whether you already have dismantling equipment. We can help assess a suitable setup and the processing factors to include in your comparison.

fr_FRFrench